FACS Header
  

 

Book Reviews

Family and Parenting

Title: A Walk to Remember
Author: Nicholas Sparks
Publisher: Random House
ISBN: 0-375-72800-7

Review: Set in a small southern town in the summer of 1958, A Walk to Remember is a timeless story of high school teens and the joy of young love.  Landon Carter, the rich guy-school jock, is taken back when he discovers his own enter feelings toward Jamie, a shy somewhat out-of-fashion student.   In every high school there is a “Landon” and there is a “Jamie”.  It is just not often they get together and the depth of the human heart is discovered through the relationship.  This is a story to remember.  Be prepared to have the tissue ready!
Because the book is brief, you may want to read it aloud to the class.  It is divided into chapters enabling the reader to stop until the next oral reading session.  The students will be left hanging with great anticipation for the story to be continued. 

Suggested Questions/Discussion Points:
1.  List the beliefs/values most likely held by Landon Carter prior to the school play? First weeks following the play?  At the end of the school year?
2.  List the beliefs/values held by Jamie Sullivan?  Did she change her basic beliefs/values during A Walk to Remember?
3.  Compare/contrast the relationships each (Landon and Jamie) had with their fathers. 

  1.  Explore the life long impact of this “young love” relationship upon Landon.
  2.  Reflect on how friends and family members had a change of heart in A Walk to Remember.  Why did this occur?  Could it have been lasting changes?  Must there be a catastrophic event do effect change?
  3. Conduct a survey on how the students think the story ended.  Did Jamie live? Did she die at a young age?  How do they want it to end?  Why didn’t the author continue the story?
  4. Do a background search on the book and author.  What motivated him to write this story?

Follow Up:  In 2002, Warner Brothers produced a film version of A Walk to Remember (rated PG)If your school permits, the film could be shown after the book has been read.  The students should compare/contrast the book and the movie. 


Title: I Am David
Author: Anne Holm
Publisher: Harcourt, Inc.
ISBN: 0-15-205161-9

Review: David at twelve years of age escaped from a Bulgarian labor camp.  From his earliest memories he has been a prisoner of the camp; therefore, functioning alone in the world outside of confinement was a daily, almost moment-by-moment, trial.  Issues of trust loom large and complicate every aspect of living—food, shelter, and clothing. 

Upon his escape, David was provided a compass, a piece of bread, and vague directions to seek refuge in Denmark by a guard who aided his leaving.  David’s strong will and wisdom, which had been nurtured by an adult prisoner, were discovered by him throughout the journey, and provided him with the tenacity to move forward. 

Suggested Questions/Discussion Points:
1.  How does the time period in which David lived make this a believable story?
2.  Would the story have been set  in today’s world?
3.  Was it environmental factors or genetics that effected David’s facial expression       and eyes?

  1. Reflect upon David’s impressions of the first home in which he was invited to enter. 
  2. Is play a learned or a natural (innate) behavior? 
  3. Conduct a survey on how the students think the story ended.  Did David and his mother immediately pick up life? Did they each have adjustment difficulties?  Why didn’t the author continue the story? Have the students continue the story either by telling or writing an ending.
  4. Do a background search on the book, author, and the time period.
  5. Research post World War II Labor Camps in Eastern Europe.

Follow Up:  In 2004, Lions Gate Films produced I Am David (rated PG)If your school permits, the film could be shown after the book has been read.  Allow the students to compare and contrast the book and movie.  Why were certain aspects completely changed in the movie from the author’s depiction?   Which ending do the students prefer, the book or the film? Did the film cast mirror your mental image of the characters in the book?
Educational websites are available for the book and film.  Go to http://www.walden.com/walden/read/david/index.php and/or www.iamdavidmovie.com/.


Title: The Giver
Author: Lois Lowry
Publisher: Bantan Book
ISBN: 0-553-57133-8

Review: The world is near perfect, and if and when a mishap occurs, adjustments are swiftly and quickly made to right the imbalance.  This is the world into which Jonas is birthed and reared.  By age 12, children begin intensive training for careers that have been pre-selected for them by a committee who take all care to place each into the best suited life work for them.  Jonas was selected to receive training to become The Giver.  The Giver’s role is most revered because he alone holds all memories of what life was like prior to the existence of the “perfect” world.  His memories include all things bad and all things good.  Jonas and the elderly The Giver, who is training him by passing on the memories, take action that was even unforeseen by the elderly statesperson.

Suggested Questions/Discussion Points:

  1. What advantages/disadvantages would there be to having wise people making 

       decisions for you?

  1. Explain why there was contentment among the children upon receiving their work

      assignments?

  1. Imagine a world without feelings pain, sorrow.
  2. Even though people enjoyed each other (children playing together, the adults being together in family units) true love did not seem to exist.  Would you like such a world.
  1. Conduct a survey on how the students think the story ended. 
  2. Did Jonas and The Giver make the right choice?
  3. Do a background search on the book and author.

Follow Up:
Before reading or assigning this text, please know there are a few disturbing scenes  (1) Jonas witnesses his father euthanizing a baby by injecting it with a needle in the head, (2) there are mild sexual references, and (3) the world of sameness may be upsetting to some children.


Title: The Notebook
Author: Nicholas Sparks
Publisher:  Random House
ISBN: 0-446-60523-9

Review: The story begins in a modern day nursing home and is told from the view point of Noah. It begins with an elderly man (Noah) reading to an elderly woman (Allie) from a faded notebook. The notebook contains a love story written by Allie when she first began having symptoms of Alzheimer’s. Allie asked Noah to read her the story daily to help her memory return. It is about two people from different backgrounds who meet one summer when they are teenagers. The setting is a small southern town in North Carolina in the 1940’s.  They are separated by WWII and Allie’s parents. Ten years later they meet again and only to find they are still deeply in love. The chapters are very short and easy to read. The chapter entitled Swans and Storms contain a brief section at the end where the characters make love. Allie and Noah are 29 and 31 at the time. The description is not graphic and written tastefully. If read orally as a class project, this section could be left out.  The Notebook is an excellent story of enduring love and devotion.

Suggested Questions and Discussion Points:

  1. Analyze personal readiness and criteria for mate selection. Identify significant factors that contributed to the satisfying martial relationship between Noah and Allie.
  2. Describe the relationship Allie had with her parents. Why were they against the relationship between Allie and Noah?
  3. Compare and contrast the qualities of Lon and Noah.
  4. Identify the type of love represented in this story. Define true love.
  5. Have the student identify issues facing the aging population.
  6. Research Alzheimer’s disease. How does Alzheimer’s impact the family?
  7. Identify and analyze the multiple adult roles and responsibilities of Noah and Allie in the marital relationship. How did it change when Allie developed Alzheimer’s disease?
  8. Relate personal values, beliefs and pressure regarding sexuality.
  9. Visit a local senior center, assisted living or nursing home and spend time with the individuals who live there.
  10. Develop a project for FCCLA on supports for families who have individuals with Alzheimer’s or dementia.

Follow-Up:
After reading the novel, view the movie The Notebook, rated P-13. Compare and contrast the plot and characters.


Title: A Boy Called “It”
Author: Dave Pelzer
Publisher: Health Communications, Inc., Deerfield Beach, FL
ISBN: 1-55874-366-9

Review:           
This book is an autobiographical account of Dave Pelzer’s early childhood. It is an unforgettable story of one of the most severe cases of child abuse and neglect in the history of California. Dave Pelzer was brutally beaten and starved at the hands of his mother while his father, brothers, and family members stood by and did nothing. In the early years of Dave’s life his family was seemingly normal as he recounts pleasurable memories of good times and fun vacations describing his family as the “Brady Bunch.” Then suddenly his life is turned upside down as his emotionally unstable and alcoholic mother began to deny him access to food, played games of torture and abuse with him, and banished him to the basement to live with little contact with his father or brothers. At a very young age Dave developed the will to live and the struggle of the pain he endured and his fight to live is a beautiful illustration of resiliency in the face of adversity. The outside world knew little of his abuse and torture when little by little his teachers, school nurse, and the school officials began to suspect the abuse this young boy was enduring. Finally, when Dave was in the fifth grade he was handed over to police authorities and “set free” from his abusive mother and home life.

Suggested Questions/Discussion Points:

  1. In the first chapter Dave describes his parents as “perfect” and daily life as “sprinkled with magic.” What activities did he and his family participate in? How does his descriptions of his early life relate to what you have studied about development in early childhood?
  2. What do you think happened to Dave’s mother? Why did she turn on him and not the other children in the family?
  3. What kind of relationship did Dave have with his father? His brothers? Why do you think his father and brothers just stood by and watched the abuse, but did nothing?
  4. What were some of the signs and symptoms of abuse that Dave showed that the school system should have picked up on earlier?
  5. Describe the different kinds of emotional abuse that Dave suffered? Physical abuse? What kind of long term effects would these types of abuse have on a child’s life?
  6. What do you think enabled Dave to become so determined to survive and not “give into” his mother?
  7. What are your thoughts about Dave’s comments in the epilogue of this book?

Title: When Zachary Beaver Came to Town
Author: Kimberly Willis Holt
Publisher: Laurel Leaf
ISBN: 0440238412

Review: Prior to the summer of 1971, Toby Wilson’s life appeared rather ordinary.  He and his best friend Cal liked to roam the small town of Antler, Texas where they live, escaping the summer heat at Wiley Womack’s snow cone stand and dreaming about girls like Scarlette Stalling.  But everything changes when Toby’s mother leaves home for good; Wayne  McKnight, Cal’s older brother, is killed in Vietnam; and Zachary Beaver, the fattest boy in the world, enters town.  At first. Toby and Cal are disgusted when they meet all 643 pounds of Zachary Beaver, but when Zachary is left alone by his guardian, Paulie Rankin, the boys befriend him and learn important lessons about the power of friendship.

Suggested Questions/Discussion Points:

  1. Examine Toby’s friendships and discuss how they affect him. Define friendship; explain what it means to have friends and what character traits you value in your friends.  What traits do you    possess that make you a friend to others?
  2. Toby’s dad tells him, “You are a lucky person if you go through life and have one person need you.” (p. 195)  Do you agree with this statement?  Why or why not?  Give examples from the book and your own life to support your belief about the validity of this statement.
  3. People all over Texas pay $2 to see Zachary, then make fun of him and ask him rude questions about how much he eats.  Have you ever made fun of somebody or called him or her names?  How did that make you feel?  Has anybody ever made fun of you?  How did it make you feel?    Why do people make fun of others?  What benefit do they derive from this?  What is the Golden Rule, and how could it be applied to this situation?
  4. Toby and Cal both suffer loss, but they handle it differently.  What factors contribute to the way they deal with their grief?  Do they go thorough the five stages of grief---denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance?  Have you or has someone you know lost someone special? Was the experience similar and did you or the person you know share the             same emotions?  How do you think you would handle what happened to Toby and Cal?
  5. How do Cal and Toby’s encounter with Zachary help them decide what kind of friends and what kind of people they want to become?
  6. Through Zachary’s move to Antler, the author shows several ways people learn to live with and to like strangers.  What are some of those ways? Have you ever had an encounter with a stranger that changed your life? How have you dealt with new kids at school, at church, or in your neighborhood?  Have you ever been the new kid?  How were you treated? How did you feel about how you were treated?
  7. Even though they are best friends, Toby and Cal keep secrets from each other. Why do the boys keep secrets from each other?  Is it ever all right to tell a secret?  Does keeping secrets hurt other people?
  8. When Toby and Cal first meet Zachary, they think he is rude, selfish, and not worth getting to know.  What changes their perspective?  Why are they willing to take risks to help Zachary?  Does Zachary appreciate what Cal and Toby do for him?  Have you ever changed your opinion about a person after getting to know him or her?

Book review and questions adapted from www.teenreads.com 

 

 
Tennessee Tech University
School of Human Ecology
P.O. Box 5035
Cookeville, TN 38505
Phone: (931) 372-3157 Fax (931) 372-6303
E-mail: Hec@tntech.edu